As middle school teachers, we know that teaching critical thinking isn’t just about having our students answer questions correctly or recall facts; it’s about getting them to engage with ideas, challenge assumptions, and think independently. Critical thinking activities for middle school students are essential for building self-reliant and thoughtful learners. Over the years, I’ve discovered a few tried-and-true activities that not only get students excited but also help them think critically—often without them even realizing it! Here are my top five critical thinking activities that truly make a difference in the middle school classroom.
1. Debate and Discussion Circles: Engaging Critical Thinking Activities for Middle School Students
One of the best ways to get students thinking critically is through structured debates or discussion circles. Middle school students naturally enjoy sharing their opinions, and a structured debate gives them the chance to do so while developing strong reasoning skills.
How It Works
Choose a topic relevant to your class or current events that can be debated from different perspectives. Some great topics for middle school students include: “Should animals be kept in zoos?” or “Is social media harmful to kids?” Divide the class into groups, assigning each group a different side of the argument. Give them time to research and prepare their arguments, then let the debate begin! Discussion circles can be a bit less formal, where students sit in a circle and discuss a topic openly, allowing for a back-and-forth exchange of ideas.
Why It’s Great for Critical Thinking
Debates push students to defend their stance with logic and evidence, helping them learn to consider and respond to opposing viewpoints. One year, my students were so passionate about a debate on school uniforms that they continued the conversation during lunch—proof of just how engaged they were!
Pro Tip
To keep things balanced, I often provide sentence starters to help students phrase their arguments respectfully, such as, “I understand your point, but I think…” These help students feel more comfortable presenting their ideas and ensure everyone’s voice is heard.
The Outsiders: Full Middle School Novel Unit
Enhance your middle school ELA curriculum with this no-prep, full novel unit for “The Outsiders” by S.E. Hinton. Includes full lessons, student activities, presentations, and graphic organizers.
2. Problem-Solving Challenges as Critical Thinking Activities for Middle Schoolers
Critical thinking isn’t just about talking; it’s about action, too. Problem-solving challenges—like puzzles, escape room activities, or real-world scenarios—are perfect for middle school students. These critical thinking activities encourage collaboration, out-of-the-box thinking, and teamwork.
How It Works
Divide your class into small groups and present them with a challenge. One of my favorites is a mini escape room I set up right in the classroom, using clues that require logical reasoning and teamwork to solve. Other ideas include STEM-based puzzles or real-life scenarios, like environmental challenges where students “design” solutions for local water pollution.
Why It’s Great for Critical Thinking
Problem-solving challenges force students to think on their feet, communicate effectively, and experiment with different strategies until they find a solution. One year, I had a group of students stuck on a puzzle for almost the entire period, but instead of giving up, they kept trying new approaches. That persistence and adaptability are the real payoffs of these critical thinking activities.
Pro Tip
Use challenges that relate to your current subject matter. For example, if you’re studying ancient civilizations, create puzzles based on historical facts or events. This adds a layer of learning to the activity, keeping middle school students engaged.
3. Socratic Seminars: A Critical Thinking Activity for Middle School Students
The first time I tried a Socratic Seminar in my classroom, I was blown away by how insightful my students could be when given the chance to explore their own questions. This activity is a fantastic way to encourage middle school students to ask thoughtful questions and think deeply.
How It Works
Choose a thought-provoking text or topic, and have students prepare by reading and annotating the material. Set ground rules for respectful discussion, and let students take turns asking questions about the text, exploring answers together in a guided dialogue. As the teacher, you act as a facilitator, guiding the discussion without dominating it.
Why It’s Great for Critical Thinking
Socratic Seminars are all about questioning and reflection, helping students develop their ability to analyze and evaluate different perspectives. When my students did a Socratic Seminar on The Outsiders, the connections they made to current events, the challenging questions they asked, and their active listening surprised even me.
Pro Tip
Start with a shorter text to help middle school students get used to the format, and consider providing sample questions as a starting point. With practice, they’ll grow comfortable taking the lead in these critical thinking activities.
4. Role-Playing and Simulations for Critical Thinking in Middle School
If you want to get students out of their seats and thinking on their feet, role-playing activities are an excellent option. These critical thinking activities allow middle school students to put themselves in someone else’s shoes, often leading to deeper understanding and critical reflection.
How It Works
Choose a scenario or historical event for students to act out. In my history class, we simulate life in the stone ages, assigning each student a different role—hunter, gatherer, toolmaker, etc. They make decisions based on their roles, experiencing the complexities of stone age social structures firsthand.
Why It’s Great for Critical Thinking
Role-playing helps students develop empathy and problem-solving skills as they consider how someone else might think or feel. It’s one thing to learn about historical events; it’s another to experience the emotions and challenges of the time. I’ll never forget when one of my students, playing the role of a gatherer, passionately argued for putting the members of the “tribe” first, drawing connections to real-world issues of inequality and collective thinking today.
Pro Tip
After the role-playing session, debrief with a discussion. Ask questions like, “How did you feel in your role?” or “What would you do differently in that situation?” This reflection cements their understanding and encourages critical thinking.
The Ultimate Stone Age Challenge
Bring the Stone Ages to life with this no-prep history project for middle school! Engage your student in a hands-on Stone Age study that develops critical thinking skills like problem-solving and teamwork. Perfect for middle school teachers who need an exciting project with no prep required!
5. Project-Based Learning (PBL): The Ultimate Critical Thinking Activity for Middle School Students
Project-Based Learning (PBL) is my go-to when I want middle school students to dive deeply into a topic at their own pace. PBL can be as simple as a week-long project or as complex as a month-long investigation, making it an ideal critical thinking activity for middle school students.
How It Works
Present students with a driving question or challenge, such as, “How can we reduce waste in our school?” Then, let them research, brainstorm, and come up with solutions. They can present their findings in various formats, such as a presentation, a model, or a report.
Why It’s Great for Critical Thinking
PBL encourages middle school students to make decisions, solve problems, and reflect on their progress, giving them ownership of their learning. A few years ago, a class project on renewable energy led students to organize a “green day” at school, raising awareness about sustainability. PBL lets students apply critical thinking to real-world issues, making learning meaningful.
Pro Tip
Include checkpoints along the way to ensure students are on track and provide guidance as needed. While the freedom of PBL is fantastic, middle school students can get overwhelmed without some structure.
Conclusion
These critical thinking activities for middle school students—debates, problem-solving challenges, Socratic Seminars, role-playing, and project-based learning—are powerful ways to foster deeper thinking in the classroom. They encourage students to engage, reflect, and think for themselves. As teachers, we’re always looking for critical thinking activities that promote meaningful engagement. These activities have helped my students grow as thinkers, and I’m confident they’ll do the same for yours.
If you’re new to any of these activities, try starting with just one and building from there. Developing critical thinking skills takes time, but with regular practice, you’ll see your students becoming more thoughtful, reflective, and capable learners. And, who knows, they might even surprise you with their insights along the way!
